Alleged illegal dumping has left two Melbourne fringe properties buried in industrial waste, with cleanup estimates reaching $2 million.
Two alleged illegal dumping cases near Melbourne show how quickly an acreage rental can become a costly waste site. In Sunbury and neighbouring Diggers Rest, landlords say tenants arranged leases under plausible pretences before industrial rubbish, including asbestos, accumulated on their properties. The cases point to a difficult mismatch: a landowner may have little day-to-day control over what arrives, yet face a major cleanup burden once a tenant leaves or can’t pay. That risk is especially stark when a property is large enough for trucks to enter and unload before the owner can assess what’s happening.
Sunbury owner reports 5,500 tonnes of waste
Brisbane-based property owner Jacob Cheu says his family leased its Sunbury property four months ago to a prospective tenant who said he wanted land for horses. The man brought his child to view the property, and Cheu said nothing initially seemed suspicious. That account shows how a proposed use that sounds ordinary can offer little warning of what follows. A viewing and a stated purpose can tell an owner what a prospective tenant says they need; they don’t establish how the land will be used after a lease begins.
The house had previously been vandalised, Cheu acknowledged, but the alleged dumping was on a different scale. He says the site contained industrial waste, including asbestos, and fears removing it could cost as much as $2 million. The distinction matters: damage to a house and a site containing potentially hazardous material raise different practical problems, and the latter can make the scope and cost of cleanup harder to establish from a quick inspection.
“They (EPA) say there’s 5500 tonnes of rubbish,” Cheu told A Current Affair. He said the Victorian Environment Protection Authority first contacted him after a fire on the property and an investigation into the rubbish. Cheu also claimed the volume of waste doubled over a weekend. If that account is accurate, the speed of accumulation would have left little time to respond once the dumping was under way. The reported tonnage is striking; the cleanup bill could be more consequential still.
He says the tenant’s stated plans gave no clear warning of what would follow. “You wouldn’t think that I’ll be financially ruined by something that I didn’t do,” he said. That fear captures the central tension in the case: the owner disputes responsibility for the dumping, while the waste remains on the owner’s land.
A similar case in Diggers Rest
Less than a 10-minute drive away, 71-year-old retiree Suji An says her 15-acre hobby farm was targeted after she leased it on June 25. Two men told her they needed space for trucks linked to a plumbing business, horses and grass maintenance. Those proposed uses, like the horse plan in Sunbury, gave the arrangement a routine explanation. But the overlap between the two accounts doesn’t establish that the same people were involved or that the cases share a cause.
An told The Age that within four weeks, almost 4,000 cubic metres of industrial waste had been dumped across the property. She says hundreds of tip truck drivers left loads of demolition material in rows, paying as little as $1,000 in cash to unload. The reported pattern suggests a site can be used repeatedly once access is available, with each load adding to the eventual removal task. For an owner, the difficulty isn’t only identifying who brought the material; it’s also understanding how much has been left and what it contains.
An says she contacted police, the council and the EPA within a week of leasing the land. She was later told she was responsible for arranging the cleanup. Informal estimates for the work range from $600,000 to $2 million, depending on whether asbestos is present. That wide range reflects a basic uncertainty in the case: the reported material and its extent don’t yet translate into a settled cost. The difference between an estimate and a final bill could be substantial.
The economics behind the alleged dumping
The difference between legitimate disposal costs and the reported cash payments helps explain the appeal of these sites to operators. Luke McCrone of Victorian Tippers United told A Current Affair that disposing of a 26-tonne truck-and-trailer load at a tip costs about $9,000. He said he had seen Facebook advertisements offering land for dumping at $1,100. Those figures describe a sharp price gap, although the reports don’t establish who placed the advertisements or whether the advertised arrangements were connected to either property.
That gap creates an apparent financial incentive to use private acreage as an informal disposal site. But the low payment reported by An doesn’t show what an operator ultimately earns or avoids paying; it does show why a landholder’s permission, or the appearance of permission, could matter to someone seeking a cheaper place to unload. Here’s the thing: once waste is deposited, the cost doesn’t disappear. It becomes a problem that may be left for the landowner and the relevant agencies to resolve.
The reported volumes also show how quickly a property can be overwhelmed. Cheu says 5,500 tonnes accumulated at his site, while An describes nearly 4,000 cubic metres arriving within a month. Tonnes and cubic metres measure different things, so the figures shouldn’t be compared directly. Both accounts, however, describe waste arriving on a scale far beyond an isolated load. And this is the part most people overlook: a lease can put access in place before an owner knows the land is being used for something else.
Cleanup exposure for property owners
The EPA says it’s increasing inspections, surveillance and enforcement against illegal dumping. In a statement, it said it uses the powers available to detect dumping, disrupt it and hold those responsible to account. The agency also warned that people seeking to rent land, particularly on the city fringe, may misrepresent their intended use. Those statements describe the agency’s approach, but they don’t resolve the immediate question facing either owner: how the reported waste will be removed and who will bear the cost.
According to the EPA, owners may be liable for an environmental hazard left by a tenant if the tenant abandons the property or can’t cover the cleanup cost. That prospect makes tenant screening and oversight a serious concern for owners of large fringe sites, where a short lease can leave behind months of work and a bill running into seven figures. If you’re working in this space, the practical lesson is that the proposed use, the tenant’s access and the condition of the land can all become relevant once a dispute begins. A plausible explanation at the start of a tenancy may be difficult to square with what’s found later.
What the cases may mean for fringe land
These reports don’t establish how common this kind of alleged dumping is, and two cases can’t measure the scale of the problem across Melbourne’s fringe. They do show why acreage can be vulnerable: land with room for trucks and loads may be attractive to operators, while the owner may not see each delivery as it happens. This is more significant than it looks. The risk isn’t limited to the value of the rubbish; it includes the uncertainty over its contents, the time needed to remove it and the possibility that the tenant can’t pay.
For owners, the cases underline how much can turn on what happens after a lease is signed. The EPA’s warning about misrepresented intentions gives that concern official weight, while the reported cleanup estimates show the potential scale of the financial exposure. And yet, the accounts leave key details unresolved, including the final cleanup costs and the outcome of the investigations. For now, the clearest message is the gap between a short-term rental arrangement and a cleanup obligation that may last far longer.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.